Method
Approach
This project has taken an action
research approach, integrating research
and practice in alternative assessment by working together with
selected
teachers, schools, districts,
and state departments of education to help them
develop alternative assessments and then observing issues of
implementation
and impact.
Our involvement over the past two years
has consisted primarily of
providing practitioners with the following training and assistance:
⏩the rationale for alternative assessment;
⏪theories of learning and instruction that underlie new
assessment and
instructional approaches;
⏫alternative assessment models and materials developed
at CRESST
and elsewhere (see Baker,
Aschbacher, Niemi, Yamaguchi, & Ni,
1991); and
⏬a process for developing
performance assessments (Herman,
Aschbacher, & Winters, 1992).
To study implementation of new assessments we
relied on observation,
interviews,
and surveys of participants. We also collected and reviewed some
assessment-related materials developed by participants in this study.
Study Sites
Several
sites were involved in the
study this year and last. Half were
interested in math assessment, and half in social studies assessment.
The
sites included:
⏯a large,
urban, racially and socioeconomically diverse unified school
district where the district office sought our assistance in
working with
a small group of
teachers to pilot alternative assessment strategies for
classroom use;
⬅a group
of teachers from a special secondary program focusing on
interdisciplinary humanities serving a
culturally diverse, large urban
school district. These teachers
attended a series of portfolio
assessment workshops as part of a
project to use portfolios for
classroom assessment and program evaluation purposes;
🔂two
middle-sized, suburban unified school districts (one serving a
relatively high socioeconomic status
(SES) community; one serving
relatively low SES students, many
of whom have limited proficiency in
English) where the county
office sought our assistance in helping
teachers and administrators to develop alternative
assessment
strategies for both classroom and district use;
🔁a culturally diverse
elementary school not bound by state education
policies, whose mandate
includes participation in educational
research projects. The administration and faculty of this
school jointly
decided to develop with us an assessment model as
a precursor to an
eventual schoolwide alternative assessment program; and
🔂an innovative elementary classroom
serving disadvantaged children
from diverse
cultural and language backgrounds. The teacher of this
classroom has been developing and implementing
alternative
assessments for the past several years.
Alternative Assessment in Social Studies
The first two sites listed above were
interested in developing social studies
assessments. The district we worked with
was interested in developing
classroom assessments that eventually could
inform districtwide assessment
practices. The
special interdisciplinary humanities program was interested